Are Black women doubly disadvantaged in the European workplace? A unique study about the experiences of Black and ethnic minority women at work, ‘Different Women, Different Places’, reveals what women of colour really think.

‘Different Women, Different Places’ evolved from the discussions and experiences of a small network of successful women and the realisation that they were not just women or just black but women with multiple identities that were inextricably inter-linked. What also emerged, however, was that being a Black or Asian woman meant different things to different people.

Intent on finding more information about the experiences of women of colour in Europe, Caroline Harper Jantuah, Director of The Diversity Practice, formed a study group with two other professional women. The goal was to move beyond previous studies that focused on problems and barriers faced by Black Women.

“The objectives of the study were to improve our knowledge about the experiences of Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) women at work and challenge the notion that Black women are doubly disadvantaged,” says Harper Jantuah. “We wanted to explore these multiple identities and produce case studies of role models for the next generation, helping employers understand their work force which will increasingly contain BME women at all levels.”

The ‘Different Women’ study is a partnership between The Diversity Practice and Katalytik, two UK-based organisations committed to equality and the celebration of diversity in the work place. Carol Compayne is the Equality & Diversity Manager for London South Bank University and a Principal Lecturer in Strategic Management, and Marketing while Jan Peters is a leading authority on women and science.

The study gathered information, through the career histories of black and minority ethnic women, of visible difference, from across Europe and also used an on-line questionnaire, face to face interviews and discussion dinners to focus on emerging topics. Dinners, sponsored by investment banking group, Credit Suisse, were held from late 2006 to January 2007. Forty-two women took part and the essence of the first dinner - the issues raised, the atmosphere and the energy were captured by ethnographers and graphic recorders.

A range of themes were explored at the dinners including individual success strategies and the notion of 'double disadvantage' and organisational style and culture as barriers to career progression for BME women. Also explored were the leadership styles of BME women and how they differ from their white counterparts, and participants debated the ideal workplace for BME women and what they considered the added value characteristics of BME women.

Some of the findings from the online survey:

More than half of the respondents are at levels 1 and 2 in their organisations, in other words hold positions akin to director, partner or senior executive (level 1) or manager, senior associate or principal scientist (level 2) category.

This refers to one's stage of leadership development (courtesy of the League of Black Women).

Survey respondents identified themselves predominantly as in the mentor leadership category followed by that of emerging leader.

41% of survey respondents spent the whole of their educational period in Europe and 19% came at a later stage for their University education.

The women were asked about how satisfied they were with their careers to date - satisfaction levels are high! 25% were very satisfied, 50% were satisfied. This is less to do with the support of their organisations and more to do with the progress they have made in spite of the challenges many of them have faced along the way.

While family was seen as an important influence on career and career choice by 57% of respondents, only 12% felt a strong influence from teachers. In fact 54% refuted that their teachers had any influence on their career.

In response to the findings, Caroline Jantuah said, “This study presents a new and dynamic perspective on the factors that guide successful BME women, bringing to light findings of value to HR and diversity professionals, government bodies, business and organisations, as well as BME women themselves. We have met and heard the stories of some amazing women and want to ensure that their voices are heard and that their strategies for success are shared as widely as possible”

Data analysis of the findings and the drafting of the report have been completed and dissemination of the findings will commence during December 2007. Fundraising activities are underway to promote the work of the project.

Organisations interested in sponsoring the project are invited to contact the Diversity Practice office 020 8408 7172 or email results@differentwomen.com

Groundbreaking Protocol for Women’s Rights Enters into Force

The Protocol to the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights on the Rights of Women in Africa came into force on November 25, the International Day Against Violence Against Women and 30 days after the government of Togo became the 15th country to ratify it.

The Protocol, adopted for ratification by the African Union in July 2003, establishes essential rights for women and girls across the continent and offers a series of advances in international law in the protection and promotion of women’s rights.

 The Protocol has been welcomed by women’s rights activists as a sign of positive change for women in the continent and 15 countries including Benin, The Gambia, Lesotho, Libya, Rwanda and South Africa have ratified the Protocol, with 38 states in the African Union yet to do so.
Source: Equality Now – SOAWR Secretariat,  November 2005

New survey reports on the real story of diversity in the UK workplace

The UK Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development has revealed the first findings of a survey carried out to assess the state of diversity in the UK workplace.  A more detailed report will be published later this year after closer analysis of the survey responses.  

More than 50% of Working Population Increase will be non-White

Other research indicates that the working age population in the UK will increase by a million in the next ten years and that minority ethnic communities will account for more than half of that increase.  The business case for promoting and implementing a diverse workforce is clear, both in terms of accessing a wider pool of labour and in recognition that a diverse workforce is more likely to attract a wider customer base. 

Allied to this is the growing evidence that companies which are perceived as ethically and socially responsible are more likely to attract and retain top talent.  Promoting the employer brand as one that is socially responsible is, therefore, key to a company’s ability to differentiate itself in an increasingly competitive marketplace.  

Background to Survey

The CIPD survey was carried out in the first quarter of 2006 and has produced important statistical information that shows what the drivers for diversity are, the kinds of policies and practices that organisations have developed and how well these are working.

Managing diversity involves recognizing all types of difference and, says the CIPD, involves “a more proactive and inclusive agenda than minimal compliance with equal opportunities legislation.”  It requires employers to adopt strategic and coherent approaches that add value to business. 

Since the first equality legislation was introduced in the UK in the 1970s, initially covering race and gender, a wide range of further regulation on subjects such as equal pay, disability, religion and sexual orientation has followed, with age regulation in employment and training to be introduced in October 2006.

Key Findings

The survey findings, say the CIPD, show encouraging signs that companies recognize the business need to progress diversity, but that “UK plc still has a long way to go before diversity management is a mainstream business issue.”

• The survey results indicate that the most important motivator for managing diversity is ‘legal pressure’, with 68% of the respondents ranking it among the top five drivers. This is followed by business-case reasons such as the ability ‘to recruit and retain best talent’, to deliver ‘corporate social responsibility’, ‘to be an employer of choice’, and ‘because it makes business sense’
• Legal compliance is by far the strongest motivator for progressing diversity, with almost one-third of respondents ranking ‘legal pressure’ as the most important reason for making progress.
• Only around 17% of respondents reported the ‘business case’ as being the most important driver for diversity in their organisations. This suggests, says the CIPD, “that the concept of managing diversity hasn’t yet been grasped by most employers and they’re therefore more likely to be missing out on potential business benefits.”
• Most respondents fail to consider the different ways in which diversity can add value to business, even though 60% recognise that diversity makes business sense. Respondents simply focus on the contribution of diversity to the bottom line predominantly in terms of recruiting and retaining best talent.
• These findings demonstrate that diversity management activities in organisations remain at a very superficial level – largely focused on training activities. The CIPD suggests that “there is much mileage to be gained in organisations making managing diversity a more systemic business process, for example, by linking diversity to objective-setting and reward and recognition, applying diversity standards and using ways of measuring the impact of diversity initiatives.”
• Although respondents believe that senior-level ownership is very important, less than half agree that senior management encourages diversity.

Conclusions from Survey

Observations from the first findings of the CIPD diversity survey, says the organisation, suggest that “UK plc is failing to reap the benefits of managing diversity.”

Diversity has so far been linked to and addressed through Human Resources policies and practices, indicating that the business of managing diversity is still far from being considered as a mainstream business issue in corporate Britain.

The full CIPD survey ‘Diversity in Business: How much progress have employers made? First Findings’ can be found at: www.cipd.co.uk

A recent study revealed that 17% of businesses polled cited the key driver for diversity in their organisation was that it makes business sense. 

ReConnect Africa asked leading Diversity expert, Fitzroy Andrew, what we really mean by diversity and as increasing numbers of Africans find employment in the West, how far are UK employers going in opening their organisations to diverse sources of talent?

The same study (see ‘The Business of Diversity’) also revealed that the need to conform to the law was perhaps more significant than the notion of business sense, with 32% of respondents citing this as the key driver for diversity. This gives a clue to what 'diversity' is often taken to mean in the UK's labour market in current times, referring to the range of policies and practices used by organisations across sectors to tackle discrimination in employment.

“Africans are employed in unprecedented numbers in the UK today”

It's worth keeping the bigger picture in mind as far as the overall employment status of Africans in the UK is concerned. There is a level of disadvantage – arguably integral to the structure of the labour market here - which has consigned successive generations to an overall experience of higher unemployment and persistent under-employment compared with a similarly-qualified white counterpart. So if diversity offers a route towards improving this situation – making sure the law works the way it should, and ensuring that more of us progress to roles which truly reflect our talents – all well and good, surely....

“The whole business of finding and developing talent rests on people making judgements about other people and their capabilities.”

And it's probably true to say that Africans are employed in unprecedented numbers in the UK today – partly because there are more of us here. More importantly, the range and nature of roles we are employed in has expanded greatly over the last thirty years. The numbers emerging at senior levels are small as yet, and largely confined to public services – no FTSE 100 company has a black person in an executive role on their board. It will be interesting to see whether this position persists over the next decade – though it is equally pertinent to ask why so few have emerged already.

“Legislation can only go so far”

So will 'diversity' lead business to open its doors to the widest range of talent in the community? To some degree, it will have little choice if it wishes to recruit at all over the next decade – people who are not white or 'British' will form one of the fastest-growing segments of the labour force over the next decade.  As important, however, are questions about the level and speed  of progression, and here it needs to be acknowledged that legislation can only go so far in creating a level playing field in employment. So far as the employment of black people is concerned, there is still much to do before 'equality' could be said to exist. We remain under-employed; in the worst cases, our very presence is still seen as threatening.

“People who are not white will form one of the fastest-growing segments of the labour force over the next decade.”

The whole business of finding and developing talent rests on people making judgements about other people and their capabilities. The emergence of black people in British boardrooms will be a critical test of whether diversity will have been seen to deliver in practice. It will show that British business believes that we have what it takes to succeed at the highest levels. I believe that we have missed out on a potential generation of business leaders in our community; I hope that we do not miss another.

Personally, I'll be happy when we reach a point where we no longer regard the presence of Africans in the boardroom as unusual. Maybe it'll happen sooner than we think, or maybe it won't. Time will tell.

Fitzroy Andrew is a Trustee of The Wainwright Trust, established in 1987 as an educational and research charity to commemorate and continue the work of David Wainwright, a pioneer in the field of workplace equal opportunities.  Fitzroy writes here in a personal capacity.

Equality and Diversity Charity calls for Nominations for the 2007 Breakthrough Award

The hunt is on for the next unsung hero or heroine of equality in the workplace. Equality and diversity charity, the Wainwright Trust has been presenting a Breakthrough Award since 1999 and is now calling for nominations for the 2007 Award, with a closing date of 30 November 2006. 

The Breakthrough Award, initiated in 1999, was created to reward those unsung equality champions, whose personal efforts have had a real impact on equal opportunities in the workplace.

The Wainwright Trust, whose members include personnel and training practitioners, trade union officials and management consultants, was established in 1987 as an educational and research charity to commemorate and continue the work of David Wainwright, a pioneer in the field of workplace equal opportunities, who died that year.

Criteria for the Award

Nominees might be law centre workers, trade union officials, individual employees or managers.  They could be personnel, HR, equality and diversity managers, although, where equal opportunities is part of their ‘day job’, they would be expected to have gone way ‘over and above the call of duty’ and obtained seriously spectacular results.

In short, the Trust is looking for unsung heroes and heroines, who have worked with dedication but without public recognition to further diversity and equal opportunities in the workplace.   As well as putting forward nominees, individuals can also nominate themselves.

The Breakthrough Award

The award itself consists of a cheque for £1,000 and a trophy designed by celebrated sculptor and jeweller Andrew Logan, whose work is exhibited all over the world.

Past winners through open competition have been a manager from Barclays Technology Services, a trade union official from Amicus (then MSF) and the lawyer who worked with her, a worker in a Bristol project to help ethnic minorities into work, a Welsh civil servant who got a gay helpline going and a woman who helped black and ethnic minority nurses to advance in the National Health Service.  

The Trust has also made special awards to two ‘backroom’ workers whom it judged to have made huge contributions to equality in the workplace, but whose names were not well-known outside the world of equality and diversity practitioners and, this year, to the ex-Ford sewing machinists and their T&G convenor whose ultimately successful struggle for equal pay was a precursor to the Equal Pay Act.

These winners are typical of the kinds of people that the Trust hopes to seek out for the 2007 Award.   They need to have made a major contribution to furthering any aspect of equality and diversity in the workplace in the United Kingdom (gender, race, age, disability, religion, sexual orientation etc), and that contribution needs to have come to fruition in the last three years.   The Trustees will be particularly looking for effort, tenacity and commitment, taking into account factors such as the resources available, the duration of the commitment and the obstacles and resistance which had to be overcome.

Application/nomination forms are available from: 
Email: wainwright.trust@btinternet.com or
on-line at www.wainwrighttrust.org.uk

Photos: The Wainwright Trust

Different Women, Different Places

…same gender, different race

A new study is launched on the lives and professional experiences of black and minority ethnic women working in Europe in 2006.

“What little research there is about black and minority ethnic women in the workplace tends to focus on the barriers and challenges we face. Yet we believe there is much to be learnt from the career experiences of those BME women who have been successful at breaking through what is sometimes called ‘the concrete ceiling’,” says Caroline Harper Jantuah, a UK-based Diversity specialist and one of the research team behind a fascinating new study into the careers of senior Black and Minority Ethnic women in Europe.

‘Different Women, Different Places’ aims to gather primary data to explore the perspective of black and minority ethnic women working in Europe today. By gaining an insight into their lives and examining the influences of family, friends and colleagues, the researchers seek to explore and understand what motivates and drives these women in the workplace and what if anything constrains their success and progression. In addition it will examine what resources external to these they draw on – or borrow – what influences them; and what else needs to be in place to enable them to realise their full potential.

Successful Women in a Bicultural World

Harper Jantuah, who runs a successful Diversity consultancy, Diversity Practice Ltd, holds an MBA and is a master practitioner in Neuro-Linguistic Programming (NLP). She has 20 years experience of working with teams and individuals in Europe, North America and Africa and reflects the profile of many successful working women in the UK and across Europe.  Increasingly her portfolio has included work with Women and Black and Ethnic Minority professionals seeking to enhance their success in their chosen careers. 

“These successful women have developed effective strategies and acquired a range of skills that enable them to skillfully navigate the bicultural world they inhabit,” she explains.  “They have learned how to manage the differing role expectations others have of them and retain a sense of who they are and what they want to accomplish.”

The output from the research which is being handled by Harper Jantuah, her co-Director, Carole Compayne, and women and science expert, Dr. Jan Peters, will share these experiences widely and provide role models for younger Black women through exploring the impact of multiple identities of senior BME women and how these have shaped and influenced their career directions. The stories of these women, gathered through discussions and interviews, will provide a resource for Black and other minority ethnic women as well as managers and HR professionals wanting to understand better the diversity of women working in Europe today.

Different Women

Carol Compayne, currently the Equality & Diversity Manager for London South Bank University and a Principal Lecturer in Strategic Management, and Marketing, has specialised in the race and gender diversity dimensions and has led and managed a number of key strategic/research initiatives in the area of equality and diversity

“It will be an invaluable resource to other black and minority ethnic women who are trying to plot their pathways to career success.”

Pointing out that there have been many studies of women and their career progress in the workplace, but few have focused on ethnicity as a related dimension of difference, Compayne and her team see this work as specifically adding value to gaps within the current body of knowledge.  Crucially, it will have an action oriented focus to ensure that there are practical recommendations to illustrate the value that Black women bring to the workplace.

The study will not only improve the knowledge of the equality and diversity community of BME women’s experiences, it will also challenge the notion that BME women are doubly disadvantaged.  By exploring the impact of multiple identities, the researchers will produce role model case studies for the next generation and help employers better understand a workforce that will increasingly contain Black and minority ethnic women at all levels. 

Research Objectives and Methodology

The research is intended to produce fifty case studies of women working in senior and middle management positions across a variety of sectors in Europe.

A web based questionnaire and semi structured face to face interviews will be used to gather primary data. The preliminary findings will then be used as the basis for discussion dinners with smaller groups of women. A framework will be developed to consider the difference of experiences across European Union countries with a colonial history as a comparator to the US situation.

Positive Role Models and Celebrating Success

A report and series of workshops will present an analysis of the data and be illustrated with the images and stories of the women who take part in the study.

“This study will provide positive role models and celebrate the success and achievements of these women,” explains Harper Jantuah. “It will be an invaluable resource to other black and minority ethnic women who are trying to plot their pathways to career success. It will also be a useful resource to forward thinking employers seeking to recruit, retain and develop the largely untapped potential of women like these in their organisations.”

For further information about ‘Different Women Different Places’ www.differentwomen.com

Walking the Talk with Diversity

“We have returned nearly 20 professionals back to the Continent in various levels in our business - including board level Directors,” says John Patterson, Human Resources Director of Diageo Africa. During his tenure, Diageo Africa has appointed senior Africans to the Executive – making the Diageo Africa Executive a truly ‘African’ team.

Diageo Africa produces, markets, and distributes alcohol, beverages and soft drinks across Sub-Saharan Africa. In his role, Patterson provides HR leadership to nearly 4,000 people in the Africa Business Unit, which comprises 20% of Diageo’s worldwide workforce, and produces sales of £750 million. Born and educated in the USA, John Patterson has been HR Director in Diageo since 2001, having previously worked for the company in roles in both North America and the UK.

Speaking to ReConnect Africa, the head of Diageo’s African Human Resources function explains how Diageo Africa has moved beyond rhetoric to truly demonstrate diversity in Africa.

RCA: In your first year as Human Resources Director for the Africa business, Diageo Africa was awarded Africa Investor’s ‘Employer of the Year’ for 2004 – an accomplishment for which both you and the business in Africa are justifiably very proud. Why has Diageo Africa put so much emphasis on the need to grow its African management talent?

JP: We believe that there is a rich source of talent and capability on the African continent. That belief has been coupled with the belief that 'Talent attracts Talent'. Therefore, we have been able to meet the needs of our growing business with highly qualified Africans that give us the competitive advantage in the talent market place.

RCA: What has Diageo Africa succeeded in accomplishing during your time as HR Director?

JP: We have returned nearly 20 African professionals back to the Continent in various levels in our business - including board level Directors.  Six out of the seven Managing Director Positions have gone to African talent.  We have appointed five Africans - two Kenyans, two Nigerians, and one Zimbabwean - to the Diageo Africa Executive Committee. There were none three years ago.  We have doubled the representation of our in-country African leaders - from 20% in 2004 to over 50% in 2006.  Correspondingly, our dependence on Anglo Saxon (US/UK) expatriates has significantly reduced from 65 in 2004 to 23 today. 

RCA: How do you believe that companies in Africa can really compete for the best African talent globally?

JP: Simple really.... offer people the chance to contribute at a significant level, develop them across African and international borders, and ensure that they are rewarded for their contributions.  This is obvious, but the real key in it all comes down to the quality of our leadership.  At Diageo, we have set clear standards for our leaders and hold them accountable for creating the conditions for people to be successful.

Walking the Talk with Diversity

 

“We have returned nearly 20 professionals back to the Continent in various levels in our business - including board level Directors,” says John Patterson, Human Resources Director of Diageo Africa. During his tenure, Diageo Africa has appointed senior Africans to the Executive – making the Diageo Africa Executive a truly ‘African’ team.

Diageo Africa produces, markets, and distributes alcohol, beverages and soft drinks across Sub-Saharan Africa. In his role, Patterson provides HR leadership to nearly 4,000 people in the Africa Business Unit, which comprises 20% of Diageo’s worldwide workforce, and produces sales of £750 million. Born and educated in the USA, John Patterson has been HR Director in Diageo since 2001, having previously worked for the company in roles in both North America and the UK.

Speaking to ReConnect Africa, the head of Diageo’s African Human Resources function explains how Diageo Africa has moved beyond rhetoric to truly demonstrate diversity in Africa.

RCA: In your first year as Human Resources Director for the Africa business, Diageo Africa was awarded Africa Investor’s ‘Employer of the Year’ for 2004 – an accomplishment for which both you and the business in Africa are justifiably very proud. Why has Diageo Africa put so much emphasis on the need to grow its African management talent?

JP: We believe that there is a rich source of talent and capability on the African continent. That belief has been coupled with the belief that 'Talent attracts Talent'. Therefore, we have been able to meet the needs of our growing business with highly qualified Africans that give us the competitive advantage in the talent market place.

RCA: What has Diageo Africa succeeded in accomplishing during your time as HR Director?

JP: We have returned nearly 20 African professionals back to the Continent in various levels in our business - including board level Directors.  Six out of the seven Managing Director Positions have gone to African talent.  We have appointed five Africans - two Kenyans, two Nigerians, and one Zimbabwean - to the Diageo Africa Executive Committee. There were none three years ago.  We have doubled the representation of our in-country African leaders - from 20% in 2004 to over 50% in 2006.  Correspondingly, our dependence on Anglo Saxon (US/UK) expatriates has significantly reduced from 65 in 2004 to 23 today. 

RCA: How do you believe that companies in Africa can really compete for the best African talent globally?

JP: Simple really.... offer people the chance to contribute at a significant level, develop them across African and international borders, and ensure that they are rewarded for their contributions.  This is obvious, but the real key in it all comes down to the quality of our leadership.  At Diageo, we have set clear standards for our leaders and hold them accountable for creating the conditions for people to be successful.

RCA: Do you see other companies emulating Diageo’s example in recognizing the power of diversity at the top?

JP:If you want to move from ‘Talk’ to ‘Action’, it starts at the top. We have not taken the ‘evolutionary' approach.... it has been far more rapid and 'revolutionary’. We have scoured the globe for the brightest talents from the Continent and encouraged them to return and to add value. We have also taken chances where, in the past, we were more conservative. It comes down to TRUST.

More Africans in our business are working outside of their home country and across borders than ever before - and we are well on our way to becoming a net exporter of African talent to other parts of Diageo. In the past 12 months, we have sent Nigerians from Guinness Nigeria plc to the USA, the UK, and Brazil.

I hope this trend will continue and that many companies do embrace this for the holistic development of the African continent.

RCA: Prior to joining the Diageo Group, you held a number of senior HR roles at PepsiCo and Lockheed Aerospace. Since coming into this role, you have been able to interact with many Africans across the continent and also to serve as a member of the Board of Directors of Guinness Ghana Brewing Limited. As an American who has worked within the African business and across the continent over the last 3 years, what has been the number one lesson that you have learned?

JP: Be yourself - authentically.  Say what you think and do what you say.  Don't allow your past files and beliefs to get in your way.  Africa has so much to offer the world and the best years are ahead for the people and the Continent.

RCA: Do you see other companies emulating Diageo’s example in recognizing the power of diversity at the top?

JP:If you want to move from ‘Talk’ to ‘Action’, it starts at the top. We have not taken the ‘evolutionary' approach.... it has been far more rapid and 'revolutionary’. We have scoured the globe for the brightest talents from the Continent and encouraged them to return and to add value. We have also taken chances where, in the past, we were more conservative. It comes down to TRUST.

More Africans in our business are working outside of their home country and across borders than ever before - and we are well on our way to becoming a net exporter of African talent to other parts of Diageo. In the past 12 months, we have sent Nigerians from Guinness Nigeria plc to the USA, the UK, and Brazil.

I hope this trend will continue and that many companies do embrace this for the holistic development of the African continent.

RCA: Prior to joining the Diageo Group, you held a number of senior HR roles at PepsiCo and Lockheed Aerospace. Since coming into this role, you have been able to interact with many Africans across the continent and also to serve as a member of the Board of Directors of Guinness Ghana Brewing Limited. As an American who has worked within the African business and across the continent over the last 3 years, what has been the number one lesson that you have learned?

JP: Be yourself - authentically.  Say what you think and do what you say.  Don't allow your past files and beliefs to get in your way.  Africa has so much to offer the world and the best years are ahead for the people and the Continent.